Hearing(s) Detail

Commercial- Suit 10769/2025, M/S Hospital Services and Sales V/S Drug Regulatory authority of Pakistan and others

Hearing(s) Detail

Hearing Date Diary Status Units / Application Witness Court
27-NOV-2025
For Hearing of Applications 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)
04-NOV-2025
Suit called. Counsel for the parties are present. Arguments heard on the application under Order VII, Rule 11, CPC. Meanwhile, on the previous date, the counsel for the plaintiff was put on notice to satisfy the Court regarding its jurisdiction to entertain this suit. Upon hearing and perusal of the record, it is observed that the primary reliefs claimed relate to regulatory actions of the Drug Regulatory Authority of Pakistan (DRAP) concerning registration and distributorship of the pharmaceutical product ???Cecolin (HPV Vaccine),??? which are expressly barred from civil court jurisdiction under Sections 11 and 46 of the DRAP Act, 2012. Although the plaint also contains contractual claims against Defendant No. 2, these are inseparably linked to the regulatory status of the product. In view of the above, the civil court lacks jurisdiction, and the plaint is returned under Order VII, Rule 10, CPC for presentation before the competent forum, the Appellate Board under Section 11 of the DRAP Act, 2012. The plaintiff shall remain at liberty to pursue independent contractual claims before a civil court of competent jurisdiction. The interim order passed earlier on 25.09.2025 stands recalled. Order announced and signed on a separate sheet. For Hearing of Applications 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)
31-OCT-2025
Case called. Counsel for plaintiff is present. Counsel for defendant No.1 and defendant No.2 are present. Counsel for intervener is present. Counsel for defendant No.2 submitted W/S. Copy to other side. Copy received by the counsel for plaintiff. Counsel for plaintiff submitted application u/s 148 CPC Order passed thereon Status-quo extended till next date. Partly arguments heard from both side further reserved. Case put off to 04-11-2025 at 10.30 a.m. for Hg on appl. u/o XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC. For Hg on application u/o VII Rule 11 CPC and appl. u/o 1 Rule 10 CPC. For Hearing of Applications 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)
30-OCT-2025
Case called. Counsel for plaintiff is present. Counsel for defendant No.1 and defendant No.2 are present. Counsel for intervener is present. Counsel for defendant No.1 submitted W/S. Copy to other side. Copy received by the counsel for plaintiff. Couinsel for plaintiff submitted C/A to appl. u/o VII Rule-11 CPC and C/A to appl. u/o 1 Rule-10 (2) CPC. Copy to other side. Copies received bythe counsel for defendant. Counsel for plaintiff submitted Affidavit-in-rejoinder. Copy to otherside. Copy received by the counsel for defendant. Counsel for plaintiff submitted application u/s 148 CPC Order passed thereon Status-quo extended till next date. Case put off to 31-10-2025 at 10.30 a.m. for Hg on appl. u/o XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC. For Hg on application u/o VII Rule 11 CPC and appl. u/o 1 Rule 10 CPC. For W/S/Objections/C.A. 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)
22-OCT-2025
P.o is on leave Counsel for plaintiff is present.. nad defendant is present Counsel for plaintiff submitted application u/s 148 CPC Order passed thereon Status-quo extended till next date. Case put off to 30-10-2025 for filing W/S. for Hg on appl. u/o XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC. For filing C/A by plaintiff on application u/o VII Rule 11 CPC and appl. u/o 1 Rule 10 CPC. For W/S/Objections/C.A. 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)
15-OCT-2025
Case called. Counsel for plaintiff is present. Mr. Abdul Sami Mahar Advocate is present and submitted vakalat-nama on behalf of defendant No.2, along with copy of authority letter, which is kept on record, counsel also submitted application u/o VII Rule-11 CPC and C/A to application u/o XXXIX Rule-1 & 2 CPC. Notice to other side. Copies received by the coubnsel for plaintiff. Mr. Abdul Sami Mahar Advocate is present and submitted vakalat-nama on behalf of Intervener, along with copy of authority letter, which is kept on record, counsel also submitted application u/o I Rule-10 CPC. Notice to other side. Copy received by the coubnsel for plaintiff. None is present from defendant No.1. Counsel for plaintiff submitted application u/s 148 CPC Order passed thereon Status-quo extended till next date. Case put off to 22-10-2025 for filing W/S. for Hg on appl. u/o XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC. For filing C/A by plaintiff on application u/o VII Rule 11 CPC and appl. u/o 1 Rule 10 CPC. For W/S/Objections/C.A. 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)
25-SEP-2025
Case called. Counsel for plaintiff is present. None is present from defendant No.1 despite service of notice. Counsel for plaintiff submitted postal receipts as well as confirmation report, which is kept on record. Counsel also submitted statement along with court fee of Rs:15,000/p which is kept on record. Arguments heard from counsel for plaintiff on appl. u/o XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 CPC. Order passed on separate sheet. Defendant No.1 is retrained from creating any hindrance with respect to the plaintiff???s claim and shall maintain status-quo till next date of hearing, save in accordance with law. Case put off to 15-10-2025 for filing W/S. For Service 0 0 SCJ / Assistant Sessions Judge VIII, Karachi (South)